Skip to main content RSS Info Close Search

ROYAL COMMISSION: Some would “rather die” than go into residential care

UnitingCare Australia National Director Claerwen Little has revealed some concerning consumer feedback during the Royal Commission hearings which the organisation gathered from online surveys and focus groups .

<p>A lack of registered nurses is leading to a lesser standard of care for nursing home residents, the Royal Commission has heard. (Source: Shutterstock)</p>

A lack of registered nurses is leading to a lesser standard of care for nursing home residents, the Royal Commission has heard. (Source: Shutterstock)

Ms Little says aged care didn’t seem to be at the forefront of consumers’ minds, with many under the impression that the system was “dominated by the for-profit sector”.

“There were no surprises in that… the cost of living, health and hospitals and employment were the top three for people. Aged care… (was) essentially not something that people really thought about until they had to,” she says.

“Sadly, some people suggested they would rather die than go into a residential aged care facility. They would rather poke their eye with a pencil than have to enter a home.”

“Expectations of people are that residential aged care is not a good place to be.”

Ms Little says the findings also show that those surveyed didn’t think they should be paying for aged care and did not have a good understanding of the current system.

“They do believe they’ve paid their taxes and they’ve contributed to the community all their life and that they should be supported in old age,” she says.

Ms Little also says current aged care regulations are “very rigid” and don’t have the flexibility to adapt to people’s wishes and aspirations.

“At the moment the regulations really bind up a system and the service so they can’t…necessarily provide that choice for the individual,” she says.

“For example, if somebody wants to get out of bed, they want to have a choice about what they wear in the morning. They want to have a choice about what they eat for breakfast.

“At the moment we have a regulatory environment which is incredibly hard in which to create an environment where choices can be exercised in that way.”

Ms Little says she’d like to see the system adopt a “continuous improvement” process that is based on outcomes and needs of the individual, “rather than the needs of the system”.

Information needs to reflect diverse aged care choices

Not everybody across the aged care system is failing and most staff are “incredibly dedicated” to the industry, says Aged Care Guild Chief Executive Officer Matthew Richter.

While admitting there are “a number of symptoms” in the system approaching a tipping point, Mr Richter says it’s important to highlight there are committed workers in the sector.

“I don’t believe that all providers are doing the wrong thing or all providers are bad or certainly that all staff are not doing the right thing,” he says.

“They’re in the industry because they care and I want to reflect on that…I don’t think everybody is failing.”

Mr Richter says Aged Care Guild is looking to develop an online collection of quality indicators, consumer feedback and potentially a rating system to set benchmarks across the industry and help consumers make more informed decisions about providers.

He says everyone is looking for different things from aged care services and should be able to search for quality indicators that are important to them, and have a platform to give recommendations to others.

“Everybody’s different and maybe you have certain preferences about how you might want to live,” he says.

“(The model) could benchmark (providers) across the industry…including things like net promoter scores, which is something like ‘would you recommend this service to a family member or a friend’. It could even include clinical benchmarks.”

Mr Richter says he hopes for the prototype to be active as early as this year.

Falling nurse numbers compromising resident care

Australian Medical Association National President Dr Anthony Bartone says findings from a members survey suggest a lack of nurses in residential facilities is compromising successful handovers after a GP visit.

“When you’re leaving for your shift to the next shift, handover provides a very important part of that exchange of information, critical and vital to the continuity of care of your patient,” he says.

“(The lack of nurses) is subjecting the Australians in said facilities to a lesser standard of care.

“It’s also having a wider issue as well in terms of the drivers of some of our members…that have worked very hard, very long in this space, both in advocacy and directly with patients, to then not continue to visit facilities because of that concern…around being involved in a lesser standard of care.”

Dr Bartone says there’s potential for medical prescriptions to “fall through the cracks” and patient’s access to medication could be delayed, adding that ongoing communication between personal care attendants and registered nurses is critical in the follow-up process.

Funding model restricting some providers

Trade union United Voice’s Melissa Coad also addressed the Commission, saying feedback from members suggests the adoption of person-centred funding in home care had lead to decreased flexibility and reduced some “paid time activities” for consumers.

“Now that they have individual budgets for each person receiving a package they have to acquit that money against that individual budget which gives them…less flexibility in moving things around where it’s appropriate,” she says.

Today the Commission will hear from the Health Services Union and consumers.


Read next

Subscribe to our Talking Aged Care newsletter to get our latest articles, delivered straight to your inbox
  1. What would you like to see from the new Aged Care Act in...
  2. Do you know an older person in need of home repairs?...
  3. New research highlights the need to financially plan for your...
  4. Last week, the National Cabinet unanimously agreed to scrap...
  5. The rising costs of providing health services is leading...
  6. The Government intends to drop the price of medications on the...

Recent articles

  1. As palliative care-related hospitalisation rates increase,...
  2. GoGoGrandparent helps older people order a ride with a simple...
  3. What do you think about the move to payday super?
  4. Are you ready to face the heat this summer?
  5. Preparation for the holidays can be stressful and tiring even...
  6. Vasey RSL Care, one of Australia’s leading ex-service...
  7. Artificial intelligence is ubiquitous with the year 2023, but...
  8. Bonni’s story is a testament to the caring nature of...
  9. If you live with hearing loss, closed-captions when watching...
  10. Meals on Wheels celebrated 70 years in Australia on Wednesday...
  11. Dementia Australia has called on Members of Parliament to...
  12. How do you say sharp at an older age? Here are some top tips...