How relaxing is yoga?
Yoga therapy has long been recommended to older people with mobility issues – but how ‘therapeutic’ is it really? New York Times science writer William Broad has reportedly angered some in America with his views that yoga can lead to strokes – and even death.
Yoga therapy has long been recommended to older people with mobility issues – but how ‘therapeutic’ is it really?
New York Times science writer William Broad has reportedly angered some in America with his views that yoga can lead to strokes – and even death.
Mr Broad began documenting various cases of injuries in 2007 which he claims were “yoga-related”, such as strains, broken bones, trapped sciatic nerves and more serious consequences — such as stroke and even death.
He cites a 1972 case study where a neurologist, Professor Ritchie Russell, wrote an article in the British Medical Journal claiming he had found evidence that yoga students turned their necks as far as 90 degrees – potentially leading to harming arteries running along the neck, causing clots and swelling.
“Reductions of blood flow in one of the vertebral arteries, called the basilar artery, are known to cause strokes in some people and can be fatal. If the clots that form go to the brain, you can have a stroke. And one in 20 people who have these vertebral artery problems can die,” Mr Broad told Radio 4.
However, Melbourne-based yoga therapist, Robyn Clarke, tells DPS News, the international claims are unfounded as injuries likely emerge due to poor teaching; but admits, “there is a risk in everything you do – you can’t say it won’t happen”.
“The only way I can see anything bad happening is if the students have high blood pressure which may potentially be increased during yoga movements, or are likely candidates for strokes as they come off the floor quickly,” she says.
Ms Clarke says “very few” people have the level of flexibility to turn their necks as far as 90 degrees as Mr Broad claims.
“Students in yoga are told to be aware of the movement of their neck, and if there is any strain you stop. If anyone has that level of flexibility and can hold it in that position, then that is very remote.
“The beauty of yoga therapy is unlike most therapies as it is driven by the person actually receiving it,” she adds.
Experts suggest the best way to avoid injury is to “not force yourself into any pose that hurts”